AddThis Social Bookmark Button
Free Dating

Heredity or Environment....which makes you you?

posted 4/13/2008 8:24:28 PM |
4 kudosgive kudos what's this?
    report abuse
tagged: environment, life, straddle
  StraddleMyNose

Some people say heredity is what makes someone, and is more important that environment. Others claim is the environment that you're in that makes who you are, and that's more important that heredity. I believe both are important, and that it's actually both that makes you you. I feel that once someone is in the right environment that person then blossoms into the person they are, and that's where heredity starts playing more of a key role after the environment part. Which is do you feel is more important to you, heredity, or environment in life?

Copy & paste to friend: (Click inside box; Ctrl + C to copy; Ctrl + V to paste)

   read more blogs!

Blogs by StraddleMyNose:
Buried Red Sox jersey to curse the Yankees? LOL
Youngest age and Oldest age of people you had sex with
Spend more money on the Wedding, or spend more on the Honeymoon?
What was your birth time and birth weight?
Would you leave after a good fuck, or shower?
Heredity or Environment....which makes you you?
Would you have sex with a one legged person?
Would you go to the bathroom while your lover was taking a shower?
Should mentally retarded death row inmates be executed?
Birthday Wishes to a good friend!


Comments:

post a comment!

GSpotGina

Apr 13 @ 8:31PM  
Environment is what shapes the person. So I have to agree there. Genetically, a person can be born with all the goods and smarts... or they can be born with deficiencies or disabilities. Either one can blossom in the right environment.
cutecarrie6969

Apr 13 @ 8:34PM  
The envirmonment can over come the genes, but the genes can't over come the environment.
StraddleMyNose

Apr 13 @ 8:37PM  
Carrie, that's an interesting way of putting it...
ValentineGirl214

Apr 13 @ 8:39PM  
I agree with the 2 comments above me. Environment makes a huge difference!!
cutecarrie6969

Apr 13 @ 8:44PM  
Thats how I've simplified a lot of the complicated causual psychology studies that I've read about....both are important, but for the most part, it genes don't do a whole lot if the right....or rather wrong...environment isn't present.
jcarolina

Apr 13 @ 8:56PM  
That was an interesting theory indeed, Carrie, and accurate. I'm a supporting example.

I was raised in countryside NC. I'm cheerful and outgoing by nature, my entire family is.

The environment I was raised in was also conducive to my personality. We wave at folks driving down the road, and speaking to complete strangers is not only normal, it's expected.

I spent 9 years in South Florida. A much more hostile environment. To speak to a stranger is often to invite trouble. A common "good morning" slowly but surely faded from my day to day activities. I found myself being, if not rude, at the least, inconsiderate.

Now I've been back home about 6 months and I'm pretty much back to my old, friendly self, although I watch people much more suspiciously than before.

I agree that it's both heredity and environment. I think the difference is that some people, like myself, are lucky enough to be raised in an environment that supports their genetic dispositions, and some aren't.

Again, Straddle, you've come up with a most interesting, and inquisitive/informative blog.

Nice!
TheAvenger

Apr 13 @ 8:57PM  
Environment plays a much bigger role in what makes a person who they are, rather than genetics, but sometimes people tend to "blame" their environment for poor judgment calls. Example: two people raised in the same ghetto, same age, same schooling, basically same type of upbringing, etc. One ends up joining a gang, gets into drugs and violence and stealing, etc. The other one stays at home, stays away from the gangs and drugs, studies and strives to be a good student, and a good person, despite the fact he doesn't have a lot of things other kids have. He goes to college, gets a degree, becomes successful. Sometimes the parents can be "blamed," to a certain extent; other times poor choices are made no matter how hard the parents try to prevent them from happening.

It's a matter of differentiation between personal responsibility, sound judgment calls, goals, direction, personality characteristics, gullibility, etc., etc.
lunanegra

Apr 13 @ 9:03PM  
I don't think genes can affect a person's turn out in life,really...of course,I have no articles to back that up with- I just wanted to post in a soon to be epic thread,lol
cutecarrie6969

Apr 13 @ 9:06PM  
basically same type of upbringing

Keep in mind I'm not trying to be combative, just trying to expand the debate....

While it may be the same basic upbringing, they still have very, very different individule experiences which in the end, over time add up, possibly causing the different outcomes you've just described. There are twin studies that support the notion that varied individual experiences, even amoung genetically identical twins reared in the same household (same environment), cause drastically different outcomes in each twin. So, as much as an overarching macro environment can shape us, ultimately, the mircocosm of our own unique lives is what affects us. The larger environment just changes the probabilities of certain events happening/certain choices being made.
TheAvenger

Apr 13 @ 9:11PM  
that is true, which is why I said...

It's a matter of differentiation between personal responsibility, sound judgment calls, goals, direction, personality characteristics, gullibility, etc., etc.
Wordsofwit

Apr 13 @ 9:18PM  
Both dimensions can be a factors and are, but to varying extents. There are exceptions in many cases. You can take children in the same family, raised the same way, same environment, and yet they come out totally different. Good blog, but there is a lot of complexity to it and humans are not an exact science.
TheAvenger

Apr 13 @ 9:26PM  
The interesting thing to discover would be the reason for those differences. Not generic reasons, but literal reasons -- if that would be at all possible. IOW, what is it about a person's genetic makeup and environment that make them the unique individual they are? Barring physiological/organic brain disorders, Is that individuality something that proves we are more than just physical beings, that we do have a soul/spirit? Is our conscience literally an aspect of who we are as human beings, and not just formed because of how we were raised? It would help explain the reason for different outcomes of children who raised in the same environment.
nobodysgirIfriend

Apr 13 @ 9:39PM  
I think I have to agree with straddle, and not just cause he is cute.
But both genes and enviorment have a big impact in who you are.

I mean if you grow up in a bad neighborhood, but your parents are polite and all that good stuff, which way are you more likely to turn out?
StraddleMyNose

Apr 13 @ 9:55PM  
Nobodysgirlfriend, thank you for the compliment, but that pic of me is from years ago, and I'm 41 now. Even at that time I hated having my pic made, even worse today. I'm still pretty hot today, just ask Kim...


There's a lot og great comments here in my blog comments, and it looks like we're all pretty much on the same page for the most part.
Sunshine79

Apr 13 @ 9:58PM  
I think it's a little to do with both. People adapt with enviroment, but still have things inherited!
sugarnspice005

Apr 13 @ 10:11PM  
Heredity is the base..but I would say it's the environment you live in that shapes you into who you are.
blackskyline4

Apr 13 @ 10:17PM  
if ur parents don't do shit then yes its ur environment... because if you don't stand for anything.. you'll fall for everything.

but to tell you the truth... it all depends on the person in generall... if you are weak minded then you could be a anything that could be around you...
jcarolina

Apr 13 @ 10:23PM  
Complexintricating complexity can be complexifyingly complex. T or F


I'm not smarter than a fifth-grader.


ThePurpleProphet

Apr 13 @ 10:25PM  
So which one is it that determines on if we are heterosexual or homosexual?

My two boys hate to read and my daughter loves it.

I'm running up the side of a muddy hill with a fifty pound back pack on. I lost my team an hour earlier. I have 20 minutes to make it to the top. Borderline impossible but I don't give up and push on harder than before. Heriditary or environment?

Or could ther be a third "something" that makes us what we are?
slohand_47

Apr 14 @ 9:35AM  
Did you watch "Changing Places" over the weekend? Eddie Murphy and Dan Akroyd figured it all out......... for $1.
Classic funny movie.
straightup_9

Apr 14 @ 10:49AM  
Perhaps, for the answer, you should compare a Jew, born in Germany, in the early 30's to a Jew born in Israel today.....Same heredity....different environment....just sayin'......

free dating | mission statement | testimonials | safety warning | report abuse | safe list | privacy | legal | 2257 | advertise | link to us

© Copyright 2000-2014 Online Singles, LLC.
OS-WEB01
Heredity or Environment....which makes you you?